Mortgage broker or straight to your bank? Refinancing in NZ
Edited by Kyle Imeson
Refinancing or refixing in NZ? How using a mortgage broker compares with going straight to your bank, how brokers are paid and what to ask them.
When a fixed rate is about to roll off, most Kiwis end up asking the same thing. Do I just ring my bank and take whatever they offer, or do I get a mortgage broker to look around for me? Both are normal ways to sort a home loan in New Zealand. They suit different people, and plenty of people use a bit of both.
This guide explains how each path usually works so you can go in with your eyes open. It is general information, not personal advice. Online Home Loans does not give mortgage advice or arrange lending. We can match you with one person if you want someone to look at your numbers.
Going direct to your bank
Going direct means dealing with your own bank's staff. That might be a branch lending manager, a mobile mortgage manager, the phone team, or the refix screen in your banking app.
What it tends to look like:
- Quick for a simple refix. If you are happy with the bank and just want a new rate when the fix ends, the app or a phone call is often the fastest route.
- One bank's products only. Bank staff can only offer their own bank's loans. They are not comparing you against other lenders.
- Banks often sharpen their offer to keep you. If you mention you are looking elsewhere, the bank may come back with a sharper rate. That is worth knowing, but it is still just one quote.
- You do the shopping. If you want to compare lenders, you contact each one yourself, and each may run its own assessment.
For a straight refix with no change to the balance or structure, going direct is often all people need. If you are unsure whether you are refixing or refinancing, read refinance vs refix first.
Using a mortgage broker
A mortgage broker works with a panel of lenders rather than one bank's shelf, and can put your application to the lenders that suit your situation.
What it tends to look like:
- More than one lender in the mix. The person we refer you to can usually compare packages across their panel, not just the bank you happen to be with.
- They do the legwork. Gathering documents, writing up the application, and chasing approvals sits with them.
- Useful when the file is not simple. Self-employed income, a trust, a top-up, debt consolidation, or a recent change in work are the sorts of situations where people often find a broker earns their keep.
Panels differ. Not every broker works with every lender, so it is fair to ask which lenders they deal with.
How mortgage brokers get paid in NZ
This is the bit people wonder about most. Most mortgage brokers in New Zealand are paid a commission by the lender when your loan is drawn down, and some also get an ongoing commission while you hold the loan. Some charge a fee as well, so it's worth asking.
A few things worth knowing:
- Disclosure is required. Once they know what advice you're after, and no later than when they give it, a broker has to tell you about any fees you might pay, any commission they'll get and any conflicts of interest, so it's worth reading closely.
- Some fees can still apply. If you repay or move the loan within a set period, often around the first two years, the lender can claw back the broker's commission, and some brokers then charge you a clawback fee. Their disclosure should spell out when that applies and how it's worked out.
- Commission can vary between lenders. Some lenders pay more than others, which is why brokers have to put your interests first, so it's fair to ask why they're suggesting one lender over another.
Refix vs refinance: which path fits which job
A rough way to think about it, not a rule:
- Happy with your bank and doing a simple refix at expiry. Going direct is common, sometimes with a broker sense-check.
- Wanting to compare other lenders for a sharper deal. A broker, or shopping lenders yourself.
- Borrowing more for a top-up or renovations. Often a broker, as it is new lending.
- Rolling debts into the mortgage. Often a broker, given the total-interest trade-off.
- Complex income or ownership structure. Often a broker.
Whichever way you go, the same costs still need netting: legal fees, valuation, break fees if you leave a fix early, and cashback clawback. The refinance costs checklist walks through them, and the refix vs refinance calculator gives a rough sketch of staying vs moving. Estimates only.
You can use both
Plenty of Kiwis get their bank's refix offer first, then ask a broker whether another lender beats it once costs are counted. The person we refer you to can also tell you when staying put looks fine, which is a useful answer too.
If you are thinking about switching home loan banks, a written offer from your current bank gives the broker something solid to compare against.
Questions worth asking a broker
- Which lenders are on your panel?
- How are you paid on this loan, and is there any fee I might owe later?
- Why this lender and structure over the others you looked at?
- What happens with my current bank's break fee or clawback, if any?
- How long does it usually take from application to settlement?
And a few for your bank:
- What rate can you offer me at expiry, and how long is it held?
- Are there conditions, such as salary credit or packaging?
- Does this change any cashback or clawback already on my loan?
How Online Home Loans fits
We are a refinance referral site, not a broker or a bank. You tell us a bit about your loan, and we pass your details to one person. They can get in touch to talk through your options, with no obligation to go ahead. We do not give advice, set rates, or approve loans.
It's a short form, your details go to one person, and there's no obligation to go ahead.
Sources: FMA, Mortgage advice; Financial Markets Conduct Regulations 2014, Schedule 21A; FSCL, clawback fees guide.
FAQ
What does a mortgage broker do in NZ?
A mortgage broker usually compares home loans from a panel of lenders, explains how each option works and what it costs, and can help with your application through to settlement. Anyone giving home loan advice to everyday borrowers has to follow New Zealand's financial advice rules.
Does a mortgage broker cost anything to refinance?
Most mortgage brokers in New Zealand are paid a commission by the lender when your loan is drawn down. Some charge a fee in certain cases, such as repaying or switching soon after settlement. Your broker has to tell you how they're paid, and about any fees, no later than when they give you advice.
Can a mortgage broker get a better rate than my bank?
Sometimes. The person we refer you to can compare lenders on their panel and may find a sharper package. Other times your own bank's retention offer is competitive. The answer depends on your loan, equity, and the lenders involved.
Do I need a broker just to refix with my current bank?
No. Many people refix directly through their bank's app or a phone call. Some still ask a broker to sense-check the offer, especially if they are also thinking about a top-up, a change of structure, or a different lender.
Will using a broker and talking to my bank cause problems?
Not usually. Getting your bank's refix offer and asking a broker to compare it is common. Be upfront with both about what you are looking at, so nobody is working from the wrong numbers.
General information only, not advice. We're a referral service. Mortgage brokers are usually paid a commission by the lender. If your loan settles, the broker's business may pay Online Home Loans a referral fee. It is not added to your loan and does not change what you pay.